

Independent in San Gimignano
- Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
- Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top San Gimignano Hotel Reviews

La Collegiata
10/10 Excellent
"From check-in to checkout, the staff was absolutely amazing. The staff was very friendly and efficient and the property is stunning.the breakfast was very good. We hade drinks in the relaxing bar area and the chef accommodates by bring a fresh focaccia and very tasty tomato and basil topping. Which led to an amazing dinner the next night.. "

Mormoraia
10/10 Excellent
"Mormoraia is nothing short of perfect! Breathtaking views, AMAZING staff and excellent food. You will lose yourself in the beauty and complete relaxation! There are plenty of activities available if you choose to be active. Just an absolutely incredible place! We will 100% be back! "

Poderi Arcangelo
4/10 Poor
"Below expectations for the price – nice location but disappointing experience
We stayed for three nights in early April as a couple. During the same trip, we stayed in other agriturismos in a similar price range, and this one unfortunately did not compare well in terms of value and overall experience.
The location near San Gimignano is very nice, with pleasant countryside views. However, the service and overall guest experience felt quite limited.
Key issues:
• Breakfast (€20 pp): limited and inconsistent selection (e.g. stale croissants, very basic fruit unless requested, no plain yogurt, eggs gone cold)
• Short breakfast window (until 10:00), creating a rush with slow replenishment
• Staff appeared very stretched, resulting in a lack of welcome and a tense atmosphere
• Accommodation: annex building requires driving to the main property for meals; not very convenient
• Kitchen available but guests asked not to use it
• Dinner: fixed menu with no choice; food was good but simple; service felt canteen-like and not particularly atmospheric
• Other points:
• Pool remained covered despite warm weather
• No takeaway breakfast offered for early departure (despite we paid for it)
• Complimentary wine (Expedia Gold benefit) only offered at check-out, hence not able to enjoy it)
Positives:
• Nice setting and views
• Comfortable bed
• Good house wine
Overall:
While the property itself is pleasant, it felt more like the hotel prioritise their convenience. "

Hotel Leon Bianco
10/10 Excellent
"Enjoyed the breakfast, the staff was friendly and helpful. The location was convienient and just around the corner was a great vista."

Hotel Casolare Le Terre Rosse
10/10 Excellent
"."

Tenuta Sovestro - Agriturismo e Winery
10/10 Excellent
"."

Relais Santa Chiara Hotel by Double Hospitality
10/10 Excellent
"We loved it! The property is beautiful, the staff are wonderful, and the breakfast was probably the best we have ever seen in Italy. So many choices. It’s an easy uphill walk to the center and it takes only 10 minutes."

Hotel Bel Soggiorno
10/10 Excellent
"Breakfast was absolutely epic—everything is made fresh from scratch daily, and you can truly taste the quality. This is a must-book spot.
The countryside terrace views are incredible—waking up to that scenery every morning is something special.
Rooms are cleaned daily and kept spotless, which makes the stay that much more comfortable.
The staff is super friendly and accommodating, always going out of their way to make sure everything is handled.
The location is perfect—right at the entrance of town, with plenty of sights to explore and towers to climb nearby. And the food throughout the area is amazing at every stop.
Overall, an unforgettable stay. Highly recommend."

Agriturismo Il Casolare di Bucciano
10/10 Excellent
"We absolutely loved our stay here. The property was beautiful, along with its views of San Gimignano from our room and the Garden Patio. The dinners there are out of this world, and I highly recommend attending. We absolutely want to go back and spend more time here. Was a great place to base out of and explore Italy by car."