Search Randall's Island Cabins

"Clean room but very old. Ac shuts off, water drips all night and the sound outside isn’t as bad as the creaking bed or hotel pipes. Staff was personable. Not worth the price."

"The place was cute and clean. The staff was extremely pleasant and helpful. It was perfectly centrally located close to the theaters. I will definitely stay there, again."

"Excellent and great location."

"This is an old-style hotel. Don't expect a coffee-maker, refrigerator or microwave to be in your room. The wifi was spotty, but that's not unusual for a NYC midtown location. My preference would be for there to be coffee available in the lobby (not too difficult). I'd also like a comfortable chair and desk in my room. Overall: Great location, reasonable price and friendly staff. I'd return to this hotel."

"Nothing"

"Clean, comfortable and very quiet. Room temp perfect. Check in and out smooth."

"No breakfast. Extra hidden charges"

"Our room here was modest in size (as expected in downtown Manhattan), but had everything that we needed. The room was clean. Staff was friendly and helpful. Security was excellent, making sure that only registered guests had access to the elevators which went up to the rooms. The location was right in the theater district, which made it handy for going to Broadway shows."

"Nice room, no issues except I did not know there’s an additional resort fee that was charged every night when I booked the hotel."