Plum Island Apart Hotels

"Clean and safe "

"Front desk staff were incredibly helpful with our special requests. Location was so convenient. "

"Our room had a lovely view of the water."

"The best, Thanks!!!"

"Overall great stay "

"Great "

"Everything was perfect"

"Very clean"

"Grace at check-in was amazing and so sweet and made our first time experience in New York City great. Rodney in Lot 15 was the absolute best, great conversation, excellent drink maker, such a great person who also gave us a lot of suggestions on the city. Jose at the front desk we encountered a couple of times. He wasn’t super friendly. A little gruff, didn’t quite appreciate his tone when we asked for more towels. We were disappointed that we never got to really experience The Look-Up which was a huge drawer to this hotel. The hours weren’t too convenient and the one time we finally were able to make it up there during open hours they were closing due to weather. We didn’t quite know what was going on as we just stepped outside and a young Caucasian girl that was working there was extremely rude and told us to hurry up and take our pictures and leave. We must have looked confused and then the bartender explained it was because of the weather and they were closing up for safety which we totally understood. The rudeness seemed unnecessary. The restaurant downstairs was excellent. Fantastic service delicious food. The room on the second floor with the free water and snack was so great and helpful especially with the hot weather. We really enjoyed those amenities. Cleaning staff was on point and did a great job and we truly loved our room and the hotel location. Even with some of the low points we would stay here again and again and recommend to anyone. "