It's the cheapest in town, and with that consideration, it's very nice. Family run, trustworthy, a local institution. Downsides are unreliable hot water, no wifi, busted chairs, a lot the housekeeper misses. But bed and a/c are good, that's the important stuff. And the balconies are great. BUT the front (balcony) rooms on the plaza are very loud. Even Sunday, Monday, pumping music til past midnight. The plaza can be picturesque, kids playing sports, etc. But if you are returning to Holbox after many years-- it has changed. Tons of restaurants, bars, commerce. Tons of tourists. Beaches claimed by clubs with paid seating. Selfies everywhere. I stayed at Arcos in 2009 and the plaza was tranquil, the whole island quiet and beautiful. The island and plaza have changed. But that's not Arcos's fault.