Search Guest Houses in Casey Key

"Clean room, close proximity to the beach and shopping district. Complimentary beach chairs and the patio is relaxing"

"We had a great 2 night stay in early May. The grounds are clean, room was perfect, everything is walkable. Will definitely return. "

"The room was modern and clean. No complaints about the room itself. However, I wouldn’t recommend this hotel for families with children. You have to walk through a bar to get to the lobby, and there were drunk people everywhere. Sketchy people roaming around."

"Property was clean and parking was plentiful, the pool and jacuzzi were both very well maintained and we were very happy with our room"

"The room was pristine, well equipped and spacious. Staff were all friendly and took time to ask where we were from and were super helpful. Breakfast was limited but what was on offer was excellent. We stopped at this hotel for a week in 2025 and were blown away by the quality of this hotel. As we were visiting Sarasota for a couple of days in 2026 we had no hesitation in booking the Carlisle again."

"Amazing bed!"

"Property smelled and was poorly mantained."

"Beautiful property and very well maintained. It’s also in a very good location as you are not far from Anna Maria Island, St. Armand’s Square or Siesta Key. The only thing - you need to pay for the beach umbrellas, but that’s alright as they offer complimentary valet parking, so all in all you still get a good value. It is also an Opal Resorts hotel, so the level of service is definitely superior to other hotels. My husband and I go to Opal hotels all the time, and we always have a great experience. We shall return! 😊"

"I liked the inclusive breakfast. Room (mostly bathroom) was not throughly clean. Couldn’t access my hotel room past a certain hour and the staff mentioned that sometimes there are issues with the keys not opening, which I found it frustrating."