The best area to stay in Mantoloking is directly along the oceanfront or the Barnegat Bay side of the barrier island.Mantoloking is a small, upscale borough on a narrow barrier island, meaning you're always close to either the Atlantic Ocean or Barnegat Bay. The main thoroughfare is Route 35, which runs north-south through the borough. Properties here are primarily private residences, ranging from charming beach cottages to grander homes, many of which are available for holiday rentals.For families, staying in a beachfront property is ideal. You'll have direct access to the uncrowded beaches, great for building sandcastles, swimming, and relaxing. Many homes come with private boardwalks to the sand, offering unparalleled convenience for days spent by the sea. The gentle waves and wide-open spaces provide a wonderful setting for children and adults alike.Couples seeking a tranquil retreat might prefer a bayfront rental. These properties often feature private docks, great for crabbing, fishing, or launching a kayak. The sunsets over Barnegat Bay are particularly stunning, providing a romantic backdrop for an evening.