Fire Island Apart Hotels

"Great for the price. In town for an event, got good rest. No frills, but good value!"

"The motel was in a great location and served our needs. Our dog could stay with us, which was key. We had 3 pillows on our king sized bed so I went down to ask for one more. They said ‘no’. That’s all. There was also a used washcloth hanging in our shower when we got there. Ick."

"The location is great if you’re flexible where you stay Suffolk County. The hotel is right next to the expressway so NYC or LI beaches are just down the highway’ish! If you like to unwind at the bar though it is very poorly stocked and staffed. Didn’t check out the pool so no comments good or bad. If you’re not looking at really hanging out at the hotel this might not your place, otherwise your room and location might be worth a try!"

"Upscale and very clean rooms. Contemporary style. Breakfast buffet available for an extra fee of USD $23.99 per person. I would say it’s worth it. Wide variety of options including fresh made to order omelettes included in buffet price."

"Hotel is grand and pleasing to look at but up close is dirty and filthy. Very disappointed for the amount I paid for room and condition of hotel. Bathroom fan did not work humidity never left the bathroom. The tv was blurry. The filters and fan system in room starts and ends very loud and bangs all throughout night. The bed was very old and sank. I think this hotel has slapped to many bandaid remodels on top of each other it’s time to replace things. 2 of the 3 elevators worked and hopefully they are replacing them not just bc they are so slow but bc of the filth and grossness all over the walls and mirrors. You didn’t want to touch or corners for fear of touching whatever is dried up going down the wall. Wouldn’t stay again. "

"There was a bed. I slept. That’s about all I can say. "

"This has to be one of the worst hotels I have ever stayed at. Honestly when we drove into the parking lot we thought the property was getting ready to be demolished. The paint was chipping off the outside walls. The parking lot had trash and potholes everywhere. The front lobby is in need of an update also. Lights off everything dark. The carpet was worn and smelled very musty and old. We were put in a room on the second floor with no elevator. The access door never locked at night so there was no security. The room is in desperate need of an upgrade. The sink never shut off. The shower was dated with soap dishes almost about to fall of the wall. TV is older with limited channels. Went to the front desk to get more towels because room service never came to at least make the bed. As soon as we got back to the room we were greeted by an employee saying he needed my dirty towels that were in my room. He told me he needed the same amount of towels that were given to me. I would save the headache of going here and drive a few miles up the road to a nicer hotel."

"Amazing stay."

"We were surprised not to find a coffee machine in the room anymore, even though the room charge was significantly more than last time. They cannot charge like a luxury hotel with not even the minimal services such as a coffee machine"