Fire Island Cheap Car Rentals & Car Hire Deals

Compare rent a car rates in Fire Island from popular car rental companies

Photo by Carole Polney
I have a discount code

Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings, and package your flight, hotel, and car to save even more.

Members save 10% more on select hotels, cars, activities and holiday rentals. Sign up.Opens in a new window

Enjoy maximum flexibility with penalty-free cancellation on most car rentals.

Explore Fire Island with Cheap Car Rentals and Car Hire Deals

* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices.

Economy

Chevrolet Spark or similar
  • 4 people
Fire Island, New York, USA
Chevrolet Spark
Economy Chevrolet Spark

Compact

Ford Focus or similar
  • 4 people
Fire Island, New York, USA
Ford Focus
Compact Ford Focus

Midsize

Toyota Corolla or similar
  • 5 people
Fire Island, New York, USA
Toyota Corolla
Midsize Toyota Corolla

SUV

Jeep Compass or similar
  • 5 people
Fire Island, New York, USA
Jeep Compass
SUV Jeep Compass

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car hire in Fire Island
View all cars

Frequently asked questions

How much is a rental car per day on Fire Island?
The lowest daily rate for a car rental on Fire Island is , based on prices found within the last seven days. Check out our broad range of options, from mini vehicles to roll-in-style rides.
What happens if I need to cancel my Fire Island car reservation?
Don't stress! If you're able to cancel your prepaid reservation at least six hours before the scheduled collection time, you may be eligible for all of your money back. It's a good idea to read your rental policy as there are some exemptions. Visit our Customer Service Portal for more information.
What are the top things to do on Fire Island?
Grab the keys to a rental car, stow your bags in the trunk and get going. With so much to do and see on and around Fire Island, your to-do list is going to be very busy! Here are some leading attractions we're confident you'll enjoy:

  • Find a place to sit, unwind and get lost in the sound of the water lapping at the shore at Ocean Beach. If you're craving a dose of vitamin sea, this is the place to get your fix.
  • A prominent structure that's withstood the passage of time, you can't miss Robert Moses Water Tower. It's a notable attraction for history buffs and regular tourists alike.
  • Fire Island Lighthouse was designed to help guide sailors through rough waters. Still an important local landmark today, it's bound to have some tales to tell about sailing triumphs and tragedies.

Why should I rent a Fire Island car with Expedia?
With car rental companies to choose from on Fire Island, Expedia makes it easy to find the perfect ride. And when you combine your rental vehicle, flights and hotel into a package, you can save more on your entire Fire Island getaway. From zippy economy models to spacious SUVs and more, Expedia will get you on the road to your next exciting adventure.
How do I find the best car rental deals on Fire Island with Expedia?
It's easy to pick up an amazing deal with Expedia. Just choose your wheels, select your dates and preferred pickup and drop-off points, and browse offers from trusted rental suppliers. Save even more when you bundle your Fire Island car rental with flight or hotel bookings.
How old do you have to be to rent a car on Fire Island?
You'll have to be at least 21 to jump into the driver's seat on Fire Island. Take note that a young renter surcharge generally applies. If you're considering a specialty ride or an SUV, you may need to be older than 21. Check the rental outlet's terms and conditions before choosing your wheels.
What do you need to rent a car on Fire Island?
You'll require a valid driver's license and a credit card in your name when you pick up your car. You may also require an alternative proof of coverage if you choose to opt out of the outlet's insurance plan. Requirements will likely vary between rental companies, so we recommend that you check before making a booking.
Can I rent a car for a month or longer on Fire Island?
You sure can. Take things a little slower with our competitive extended rentals. Simply enter your travel dates and pickup and drop-off locations, and we'll track down the best long-term car rental deals.
Where can I find a Fire Island car rental if I am younger than 25?
You'll have to research the age policy of the Fire Island rental provider you're considering. Rental companies normally apply a young driver's surcharge to people aged 21 to 24  so make sure you understand what extra costs you're up for. No one enjoys being hit with unwelcome surprises at the rental desk, so always study the fine print before confirming your booking.