59 St. - Columbus Circle Station Apart Hotels

"A great location and great value for New York "

"Location was prime, minutes walk from the metro, shopping, and popular bagel spots. Staff and service was great and quick to assist. Cafe lobby: 10/10 iced lattes and smoothies. Would definitely stay again. "

"Nice hotel on the heart of Times Square. Very helpful staff."

"Great location for dinning, travel, and shopping. "

"I loved the easy valet parking, the restaurant and the high floor. "

"It was good overall, with live music at night, a bar inside the hotel, super close to Times Square, and good restaurants. everything was clean in the room, and very good service from the Dominican receptionist (I don't remember her name), I only know that she was magnificent."

"Everdine staff are not all on the same page as to how things work. There was some small issue with our breakfast vouchers one day (not a big deal), the next we were told that we could not get coffee and juice and that it was one or the other and another day we were told there was added charges for requesting cheese in the scrambled eggs. 3 different staff. Also, don’t hold your breath for refills. They won’t exactly offer except for the water. Over all the Everdine service was lukewarm at best. The rest of the hotel staff was warm and welcoming!"

"Beautiful older property, well maintained, great staff. Amazing lobby. Love the TickTock Diner! We arrived in early afternoon and planned to drop our luggage off with concierge, but room was ready and we were able to go up directly. (The front desk gets completely slammed at the regular 4pm check-in time!) The New Yorker hotel is very conveniently located one block from Penn Station and a few blocks from the bus station, and very close to many subway lines, including the A/C/E stations on the same block. We enjoyed walking across town to museums and found the streets very safe with wide bike lanes and a long crossing time at the lights. We will definitely stay here again!"

"Great stay! The rooms were Extremely comfortable & clean! The staff was really friendly and helpful. This hotel offers a great price in Times Square; walk to everything because you’re in the middle of everything! I highly recommend! "