Barnum Island Romantic Holidays

Great hotel experience overall. The location was perfect for a tourist and not too hectic like other parts of NYC. The hotel has a very cool bar and terrace. The rooms were clean and included thoughtful complimentary things. Staff were super nice and helpful. Will definitely stay there again!

I love this property.

The ONE great thing about this hotel is the staff. CAUTION: Take the bad reviews about noise and heavy vibration VERY seriously. I did not seek a new room because I spent my wakeful hours wishing I'd read all the negative reviews before booking. The issue exists regardless of floor. Yeah, they'll respond with "had we known we could have responded". They KNOW, and they clearly don't care. Its a known issue. The sound is as obnoxious, strident and grating as an idiot who drives around town with a woofer blaring in their car - only this lasts ALL night! Ear plugs and a pillow over your head won't help. It's not just the clubs, but the acoustics in general from people walking and talking loudly through the halls in the middle of the night, to noise from neighboring rooms. I could hear the squeak from someone wiping fog from the mirror like I was in the room! A hotel has a simple job - shelter and comfort! The PUBLIC rather focuses on pushing out their restaurants, bars, nightlife and events with Instagram moments styled at every turn. But you will NOT sleep any night their clubs are open.

Wonderful stay ! Great location , attentive staff, elegant hotel , great breakfast and wine hour . Highly recommend !

The Wall Street Hotel was fantastic. One of the best hotels I've stayed in. The room, and the hotel in general, were extremely clean. Very clean sheets and bedding which I appreciate. The floors in the bathroom were heated and the towels were big enough for an actual adult, not a toddler. The front desk personnel were extremely helpful and accommodating. The breakfast at La Marchande was fantastic, and again, and extremely clean establishment. We had a wonderful stay and will definitely be back again!

I stayed with a friend. We had a lovely big room with 2 double beds. There was always hot water. The shower was pretty good. The beds were comfortable. The location in midtown was very good for exploring New York. The swimming pool was too cold. We loved using the steam room but it’s a shame there is no hot tub or spa-like services available.

Wonderful stay ! Great location , attentive staff, elegant hotel , great breakfast and wine hour . Highly recommend !

This hotel was fantastic. Everything was so seamless and everybody was very helpful. The rooms are a little small, but they are very nicely updated and well cleaned.

The Wall Street Hotel was fantastic. One of the best hotels I've stayed in. The room, and the hotel in general, were extremely clean. Very clean sheets and bedding which I appreciate. The floors in the bathroom were heated and the towels were big enough for an actual adult, not a toddler. The front desk personnel were extremely helpful and accommodating. The breakfast at La Marchande was fantastic, and again, and extremely clean establishment. We had a wonderful stay and will definitely be back again!

Wonderful stay ! Great location , attentive staff, elegant hotel , great breakfast and wine hour . Highly recommend !

This hotel was fantastic. Everything was so seamless and everybody was very helpful. The rooms are a little small, but they are very nicely updated and well cleaned.