Book a Penn Yan Cottage

"Terrible experience here. Me and my fiancée got a bacterial infection from a dirty and not maintained hot tub. We brought it up with the host and after 3 days they told us they wont refund or compensate for anything. Absolutely terrible do not go here unless you want hot tub rash from a dirty hot tub. Vrbo also refused to refund or compensate and thats ridiculous. "

"Facilities were clean but stale. The staff was efficient but not welcoming. Average stay for the price."

"Not enough staff. Advertises a restaurant online but there is not one. But a cute, clean hotel."

"Room was comfortable, clean and very quiet! Would stay again"

"Great location, clean rooms and hotel. Fantastic staff."

"This was the second time we stayed overnight and have been to property for dinner separately too. This small resort is just the most quaint little spot in the finger lakes. We are local and love coming here for a little weekend relaxation and to celebrate 50th bdays. We were able to check in a little early & greeted with champagne when we arrived. The weather is chilly this time of year but they still had the pool & jacuzzi heated and open until 10pm. After checking in we had celebratory drinks and appetizers with our group in the Sand Bar restaurant in the resort, everything was delicious, and we had such a great server. We didn’t have dinner at the resort this time and decided to walk over to a restaurant near the resort called Nolan’s for our Italian craving crew. We really enjoyed hanging out at the Rose Tavern for late night drinks. There is a room right outside the entrance to the tavern with comfy seats and tables and a warm fireplace. We met up there after enjoying the hot tub & pool with our group of friends to celebrate 3 50th bdays. I highly recommend the inn, rooms are clean, staff in hotel and restaurants are very friendly and will be staying again in the future during the summer instead as the the resort is blooming with flowers everywhere, there are bicycles offered to explore the area, and the outdoor pool, dining and sunsets are amazing. We didn’t have time to try the spa, but will definitely do that next time. Thank you for the a great stay!"

"I've stayed at this location on two times now. The house is adorable, the hosts are very accommodating- highly recommended!! "

"Great location. Lots of room for everyone. "

"Accommodations, location…all as advertised. Great stay! "