Pet Friendly Hotels & Resorts in Fire Island from NZ$259

"Building felt out of date and upkeep was lacking. Cleanliness acceptable"

"Breakfast was fresh at the staff were very attentive. "

"If you want to step back into 1977 Long Island, this is your place. Really disappointing. First entire day we had no hot water in the shower. Finally we had to change rooms. What a hassle. Hotel didn’t even apologize…or offer to help us move our stuff. Fridge in the room didn’t work and there was no way to adjust the lukewarm temperature. Be careful of the hot tub…looked dirty…lots of little things floating around in it. You really get nothing except your room. The lady in the coffee shop is a gem though…seems like she was the only one who smiled in the whole building…such a character. Location was really good for if you are golfing at Bethpage. But next one I would get a house rental in one of the neighborhoods around the golf course."

"The hotel was rundown, but it looked like they might be making improvements in the future."

"Decent motel"