Photo by tom owens
All hotels in Shelter Island, New York
Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide
All hotels in Shelter Island, New York
We have found 4832 Shelter Island Hotels
- Old Lyme Inn
- Haven Montauk
- House on Chase Creek
- Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast
- Village Motel By OYO Clinton
- The Surf Lodge
- The Rams Head Inn
- Stirling House Bed & Breakfast
- Bridgehampton Inn
- The Blue Inn At North Fork
- Head of Pond House
- Arbor View House B&B
- The Inn Spot
- Duryea's Sunset Cottages
- Sea Haven Resort Motel
- Water's Edge Resort & Spa May 23, 2025 - May 30, 2025
- The Drake Inn
- North Fork Guest House
- Jedediah Hawkins Inn
- The 1708 House
- The Crow's Nest
- Bee and Thistle Inn
- The Baker House 1650
- Zey Hotel
- Sprawling Farmhouse in Private Beach Community
- Ocean Colony Beach and Tennis Club
- Maison Vivienne Southampton
- Shelter Island House
- SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House
- Amagansett Farmhouse Short Walk to Atlantic Ave Beach
- Cozy Farmhouse Secluded Community w/ Private Beach
- 380 Inn
Let Expedia take you to the best Hotels in Shelter Island. You'll find the largest selection of hotel deals, discount prices, and cheap hotel rates on reservations anywhere in the world. Expedia, the leader in world travel, gives you customer reviews, maps, and the best selection of hotels near landmarks and attractions.