Top Hotels Near Haunted Theatre in Mackinac Island from NZ$113

"Breakfast cold. Pool close. No soap or shampoo on the room "

"1$ Breakfast was good. Would have loved a hot chocolate and oatmeal by the hot water. #2 Absolutely needs a TOWEL BAR and more HOOKS!!! One little hook was on the door back and held one pair of pants. And one outside the bathroom in the entrance where one coat was on. So.... Not one place to hang your wet towel at all. Or no place to hang your small towel by the sink.... So I used a1000 towels. 3# They had three liquid dispensors in the tub and two by the sink. How nice! But Not one of them had a drop of shampoo, creme rinse, or body wash on them. Bottles were empty. Loved the lemon soap bars. 4# Shower head was damaged. 5# Housekeeping did not have supplies on hand. A toothbrush. 6# need a map in the rooms to the breakfast and tell us the hours.oo. "

"This place was absolutely perfect to call home for the night! I went at the end of March so it was very cold and a lot of the shops were still closed for the season but I loved every bit of the island and this lodge luckily stays open year round which saved my butt! This place is clean, quiet, comfy, so so close to the water and right downtown where all the good stuff is! I’d stay here over and over again. The staff was so very friendly and helpful, we were thrilled with our stay!"

"Hospitality was wonderful and clean rooms!"

"We stayed in mid October 2025 and would definitely go back. "

"Clean, spacious, and comfortable. An awesome setup for larger families. Plenty of sleeping space, so long as you’re ok with using the couch and fold out beds, which were also very comfortable. Awesome view of the lake and Mackinac island. Unfortunately, we weren’t able to take advantage of the deck and patio, but they would be fantastic in the winter. Kitchen has everything you could need to cook. "

"Very nice place to stay, it was clean and quiet. The staff was nice and friendly. "

"Nice "

"courteous staff with wonderful breakfasts. It's a very old establishment and very comfortable. "