Top Hotels Near Great South Bay in from NZ$184

"The staff was amazing. "

"I absolutely love Fire Island! The location was perfection. A couple of minor things…no towels in room and tv not working. Attention to detail! "

"This unit was great. It's clean, quiet, and centrally located. It comes with 2 bikes which is a huge bonus (the rentals down the street are 40/day). It also has beach chairs and towels which is nice. We would definitely stay here again. "

"We had an incredible stay. Robby and Joe were so welcoming and set us up to have a fantastic time. The house is clean, modern, and perfectly equipped with everything you need. You can’t beat the location- just a few blocks from the ferry and downtown cherry grove. We enjoyed perfect sunsets on the bay and easy beach days. We wished we could’ve stayed for longer! We can’t wait to come back next year!!"

"The door code gave us problems but the owners gave us a key instead for the side door.The outside shower and toilet were great. There is only one bathroom downstairs which was a little annoying but we made do. Overall it was the right fit for me and my 3 kids."

"Wednesday to Sunday in fire island for a bunch of first timers and we are definitely going back! "

"Clean and comfortable room. Great location. "

"We stayed over MDW 2025. We docked our boat at Flynn's just a few blocks away which made this property ideal. We rented all three units which was perfect for our group of adults, kids, and teens. Each unit was well equipped, very clean, and plenty of showers and bathrooms. The outdoor showers were awesome. We would definitely rent this location again! "