Top Hotels Near Fish Island Marina in St. Augustine from NZ$243

"Housekeeping was rude. They started knocking on our door at 9AM when check out was not til 11AM. When we said we weren't ready yet, the guy tried opening our door twice and started banging on our door again. They did the same to the room next to us and left when the other occupants told him that check out is not until 11AM. Ruined our stay in St Augustine. "

"Our stay was quite pleasant! The room was very comfortable, clean and had what we required. Breakfast was fine. Our only issue was having to pay for parking "

"Even though my room was right next to the lobby, it was still pretty quiet. I also LOVED how close it was to the beach. "

"We stayed for spring break for three nights April 6-8 and unfortunately the weather did not cooperate with us so we didn’t get to use any of the amenities but the pool tiki bar and fire pit area all looks great. It was just way too windy and cold for us to really experience them :( Staff was very friendly upon check-in and at the restaurant during breakfast. "

"This was our second time staying at this hotel. Our first stay (11/2025) was absolutely amazing so we were excited to come back. Unfortunately, it was not the same experience. When we arrived the front desk over night staff was rude and unhelpful. When we asked for a late check out (due to arriving at 1:30 am) she stated it would be an extra $25 upcharge, although on the website it stated there is a $0 upcharge for late check out. Our room smelled HEAVY of cat urine/cat liter, our hotel phones were not working, and there was mold on the shower door/shower floor. We paid almost $400 for a one night stay in room for 6 people but had 3 towels in the bathroom for all of us to share. All this was mentioned to the front desk staff in the morning and all that was provided was an apology. The amenities were good- breakfast, gym, staff at the pool were very friendly and the beach was beautiful. Unfortunately due to inconsistency in experiences from one stay to another and condition of the hotel room, we will not be coming back. "

"Brand new hotel two minutes from the historic district. Highly recommend and would stay again."

"Parking was easy and free. Parking lot felt safe and cobblestone felt historic and appealing. Beds were extremely comfortable. Room was very clean and nice. Breakfast was a delight. Egg casserole was great and the biscuit and gravy was the best in Florida. "

"The location was great! And the host are so easy to communicate with. We so enjoyed our stay "

"The rooms require improved cleanliness, and the curtains and shades also need to be cleaned. The price per night does not correspond to the condition of the rooms. "