Top Hotels Near Finger Lake in New Carlisle from NZ$121

"The staff was incredibly friendly and kind."

"Beautiful rooms and staff definitely recommend "

"Very clean room and friendly staff"

"Wish their was a better option for breakfast on Friday morning. Edgewater was overwhelmed with Timbers being closed waited 20 minutes and still couldn't get a cup of coffee. Would think since Timbers is closed Friday mornings Edgewater might be better staffed for the rush. Also would like to see The Buffet open with a breakfast spread. Otherwise just have to go down the road which i'd like to eat before i go."

"wasn't informed about the $16.95 "resort fee" when I booked the room .... won't make that mistake again"

"The 'continental' breakfast costs $18.00. Way too much fir eggs, muffins, bacon and waffles. The room was noisy. The AC unit ead noisy. Children running up and down the halls yelling and slamming doors. The room looked out over the lobby where people socialized until very late. Parking costs $15.00 a night. Very low clearance, wet and dirty. A broken water pipe has left puddles. Repairs are ongoing throughout the building. The worst experience of my life! "

"Very nice in every way."

"The conditions of this property were abysmal. The lobby and hallways are unkept with an odd smell and the rooms disgusting. Upon entering the room we very quickly discovered a blood stain on the sheets of the bed, stinkbugs, and a loose pill on the ground. The lounge chair and ottoman also had a cheap cover each to hide the age and general state of them. We immediately left and this far have been refused a refund. Absolutely disgusting and appalling."

"The room was clean and well appointed. We had everything we needed. This is an older inn undergoing some renovations. We would opt to stay here again instead of the chain hotels. Breakfast was adequate and the location was phenomenal right on Pine Lake. "