Top Hotels Near Edgartown Lighthouse in Edgartown from NZ$237

"Lovely room, separate bedroom, and a fully equipped kitchen for cooking those large lobsters from the local fisheries in Menemsha. Clise to everything in Edgartown. A big plus was a parking space for the car. Rooms have private entrances. Almost dont want to write a great review, there may not be a room for me once this gem is discovered. "

"Clean and comfy room and bed. Excellent location!!"

"The area was safe and the dining experience was great. "

"Great location, meticulously maintained property, and superb service from the entire staff. Very accommodating."

"I wish to commend Area Hotel General Manager, Carlos Guzman, who sat at the front desk while his staff had called out sick. Carlos was very kind, courteous and curious about what brought us to the island, and when he learned of our nephew’s wedding and our unmet hope for 2 adjoining rooms to accommodate a daughter and grandchildren, he unsolicitedly upgraded our room to a 2 bedroom suite, which offered the five of us plenty of room and sufficient sleeping areas, as well as a full sized refrigerator and kitchen, to enjoy each other’s company throughout the wedding weekend. Carlos Guzman was personable, fun and funny, and went over and above any expected level of service. He spoke highly of and with great loyalty toward his employer and engaged with us by sharing some of his knowledge of and experience with island life and the people who make the island livable. This young man has earned our praise and I believe, his company’s positive attention."

"Amazing Hotel and location. Close to shops, restaurants and free public transportation steps away. Super clean and upscale feel. Highly recommend the Sydney in EDGARTOWN."

"Wonderful hotel in a great location. Quiet and quaint. "

"Breakfast was fantastic. Staff was terrific. Due to allergies fortunately not pet friendly. "

"Quick overnight, nice facility room better than adequate."