Top Hotels Near Katama Farm in Edgartown from NZ$301

"Love the lobby and amenities"

"Property and room were very clean and comfortable. The one thing I wasn’t aware of is there is no staff on site if you check in after 5:00pm. I had to call the number on the front door, download an app and complete several steps to access my room via phone. Once I got through that, the rest I’m of the stay was fine. The location was convenient with a restaurant/bar across the street and other stores within close walking distance."

"The hotel location is beautiful. The building is well kept and clean. The staff was amazing! We loved our room overall but there were a few minor inconveniences: 1. The shower handle kept getting stuck and was hard to turn off. 2. We went in April and the room got very hot at night. You couldn’t change the room thermostat from hot to cold. So they told us to open the windows, which let a bee inside our room because the windows had no nets. "

"Good"

"Great Stay, Everything we needed. Thank you."

"Nice and clean house, good location on the island, nice neighborhood "

"A beautiful property with a very well-maintained and well-equipped home. Welcoming and comfortable all around. Communication from Steve, the owner, was rapid, efficient, helpful, and thoughtful. We can imagine the grounds and pool in full action for an in-season visit! Already considering another visit in 2026. Thank you. "

"Rented this home for the second time. Perfect size for our family. We were there once in October and just came back from 4 days in December. The house was very cozy and the kitchen is well stocked with utensils pots and dishes. We will definitely rent again."

"Amazing! "