Book a Cudjoe Key Cottage

"The room was clean and fine enough. The outdoor area was common and offered no privacy. For some reason, there were 4 pools - but they were all very small and right next to each other, so I didn't understand the purpose. Would have preferred just one larger pool. During my stay there were a large number of European guests who had no regard for the people around them, often being loud and obnoxious. The pools close at sunset. Too early in my opinion. The one restaurant is basically just an outdoor bar with typical bar foods - overpriced and underwhelming. The property is surrounded entirely by a white picket fence and large hedges, making the property feel claustrophobic. Overall, it was fine. But I wouldn't stay again."

"Would rate it much higher but they never got the AC working right in our room. It ran but never got the room below 75 even at night. We asked 3 times for it to be checked/fixed."

"Great rooms"

"Awful"

"Staff very friendly and helpful with anything we needed. The hotel is an older hotel but very well maintained. The rooms were clean. I was traveling with my 2 sisters. I had been to Key West before and stayed at a hotel down town. I found this hotel rooms to be a bit bigger. There was transportation available every hour to and from downtown & Smathers beach. I felt the location where we were dropped off was a great area for walking and right near Duval St. There was breakfast provided daily with many options. Cold water container always filled near bar/pool area as well as inside reception area. On checking we were handed a daily buy one get one drink card for the bar. The pool was awesome with plenty of lawn chairs to sit, in and out of shade. I would stay here again."

"The property was beautiful. Though we didn't get a chance to use the pools they were very nice looking. Would definitely stay here again"

"Rooms are great. Whoever designed them has a clue. Gave off a good vibe. Not like your average hotel. Cool painted back drop and good photographic art on the wall. It really makes a difference. Nice big modern TV. Binge watched paranormal shows the whole of the first day, it was that good. Pool is quite shallow but it's ok if you don't want to swim around in it. Free shuttle to the old town. There are annoyingly loud roosters all over Key West but if you enjoy a C**k a Doodle Doo at 4, 5, 6, or 7 am, and the rest of the day, you'll love it. It's a cool place to stay."

"Enjoy hotel nextdoor"

"The hidden resort fees were absolutely ridiculous! $40 a day, plus $5 a day plus $150 coverage without any explanation. This property is located directly next to the airport and they do not provide a shuttle service to pick you up. We used Uber for everything, another extra expense. ( The Hampton Inn next door had a shuttle that went everywhere)"