Holiday Homes in Caroga Lake

"Everything great except the weather."

"Rustic, authentic Adirondack Lake House with plenty of room for the family. Plenty of outdoor equipment including a great dock to fish off of. Indoors was cozy with plenty of warming options on chilly nights and rainy days. Kitchen was well equipped and very spacious. Multiple dining areas including a very nice sun porch. Would definitely recommend if you are looking for authentic lake house experience."

"We stayed in the Pulpit House previously and once again found it perfect for a relaxed gathering of friends. Spacious and well-equipped, it is full of interesting detail and atmosphere. Erin is unfailingly helpful and communicative. We look forward to next time!"

"As advertised. Helpful and responsive hosts. Thanks for making a great trip for our large family !"

"We had a great stay at the South Shore Retreat House! Fully accommodated our family of 12 adults and six children. We were hosting a party at Tinney's Tavern in Lake Desolation and the South Shore House was a perfect place to retreat to at the end of the evening! Kyle was super responsive to any questions we had. Highly recommend !"

"We had a blast staying at this property. The house was super clean with plenty of space and beds. When we weren't at the lake, we loved hanging out in the basement playing ping pong. Host was communicative and check in and out was seamless. Highly recommend!"

"We were looking for a quiet, peaceful, lakefront cottage and Firefly Lodge delivered. We enjoyed coffee on the dock every morning and were joined by the ducks and loons. The highlight for us was watching the supermoon rise over the lake. It seemed like you could reach out and touch it. The owners were great and made sure we had no problems. We hope to be able to visit again"

"Had a great weekend, enjoyed the hot tub and fireplace. The views were beautiful, would definitely stay there again."

"Great Lake Rental. Easy to get to the lake. Clean and great for families"

"Great experience. Clean, great communication, ez access"

"House is in a nice location. The pictures were photoshopped on the listing to make the wood appear to be a more modern wood tone than it actually is. Not a huge deal but definitely something I noticed upon arrival. The bath towels provided by the house were bleach stained. No AC in bedrooms. Plant overgrowth on back deck. Ice maker doesnt work in freezer. Minor issues that could be addressed to provide a nicer experience for guests. Overall the house was not bad and we had a nice stay, but not 5...

"Charming place. Very clean. Great views of the surrounding valley. It was a convenient location for visiting friends and family in the area."

"1890s Elegant mansion with great bones and almost completely restored. Pool would be big plus in summer and game room definitely a plus, though some equipment needed repair. Great location for our short family reunion of 6 adults and 3 tweens. Would worry about kids less than 10 or limited mobility folks as stairs quite tight or spirally and high. Does have first floor bedroom but a bit of distance to the single well appointed bath on that floor. Kitchen quite well equipped and even had a wide...

"The house was clean and comfortable. Had a great welcome package with a wine and some information about the area. Hope to stay again!"

"We had a great family week at the Lodge. The house was very comfortable for our party of 5 adults and one child, with three bedrooms and 2 full baths on the top floor and a small fourth bedroom and full bath on the main floor. All of the bedrooms have window air conditioners, but the rest of the rooms in the house are not air conditioned. The main floor also has a large and well-equipped kitchen, large dining area, and living room/den spaces. There are decks off the dining area, off the master...

"Great place for a close drive to Gore mountain for a ski trip."

"This cabin-like house is lovely and the location is beautiful. It is spacious enough to easily accommodate our family of eight. The owner is responsive to queries. Be forewarned, though, that renters are required to provide their own sheets, bath towels, and kitchen towels (which was not mentioned in the listing)."

"Great house, beautiful location, great experience with the host."

"The house and location are even better than the pictures. The hosts are so welcoming and helpful. It was the perfect get away with our pooch. The fenced area is so convenient. The house itself is so cozy and has everything you could possibly need and lots of extras. We’re hoping to go back in the summer and really enjoy the lake."

"Everything great except the weather."

"As advertised. Helpful and responsive hosts. Thanks for making a great trip for our large family !"

"The house was clean and comfortable. Had a great welcome package with a wine and some information about the area. Hope to stay again!"