Upper Montclair Holidays from NZ$2,859

Staff was wonderful, food great, bed really comfortable with nice bedding, location great. It needs to be updated. The carpet is old, the shower tiles are old showing age, cracking. There wasn’t a place to sit except at an 8 foot cafeteria table that was beat up, and this was an upgraded room. I get the concept, and love the idea, but it opened in 2009, just needs to be refreshed.

Great room, great staff, great bar

The front desk staff was really friendly and welcoming. Room was clean.

Very helpful staff and clean room

Charming art deco property with in-house diner and Italian restaurant. Very close to Moynihan Train Hall. We experienced a very long wait for check in. Unsure if this is typically the case at 9:30 PM on a Saturday, but only 2 agents were staffing the desk and a third eventually came out to chat up the line of nearly 15 parties. He was very friendly. We stayed during an incredibly cold weekend, so the room's draftiness likely couldn't be helped due to the age of the building. Even with the heat turned to high, there was still a breeze at the windows. Our suite was clean and spacious for NYC. The housekeeping staff we encountered were all friendly and accommodating. Would likely stay again, if the weather is better, due to location and price.