Book a Sugarcreek Cottage

"Carlisle Inn Walnut Creek was very nice, quiet and relaxing. The entire staff gave excellent hospitality. The room in its entirety was very clean, including the bathroom. I surprise my twin sister (from Pennsylvania) with a two day stay. She was very surprised and happy and couldn’t stop saying how much she loved it. It was so relaxing to sit on the balcony and enjoy the nice spring breeze. The entire staff at the Inn was very nice, from check-in to the time we left. Let me not forget the wonderful ladies who served the breakfast. I’m sorry I I did not get their names but they worked the mornings of April 16 and 17th. I will definitely be coming back for a stay. If you’re looking for a place to relax, enjoy the breeze and the wonderful scenery. This is the place to go. There were wonderful places to shop and explore. The Amish people community, a very welcoming and inviting."

"Stay was very nice. Regina checked us in and was exceptionally helpful in ensuring we had everything we needed."

"We have stayed at most of the hotels,and bed n breakfasts in the area and this one is probably one of the best! Its clean,roomy and very friendly and accommodating.....just beautiful"

"Best place to stay in Coshocton. "

"The “hot” tub was barely lukewarm. That was too bad because the jets seemed to be working great. There are two gas powered fire pits in a lovely area. Unfortunately, one of the fireplaces would not stay lit. We reported it thinking it just needed more propane. That was not the answer. The breakfast consisted of the usual buffet breakfast choices but mostly cold with rubbery scrambled eggs. But the saving grace was the cinnamon rolls! Also, the room was spacious and clean!"

"The hotel was very clean, the room was also very clean, the breakfast was very good and hot foods were hot and cold foods cold. Parking was fine."

"Breakfast pastries were delicious...room was clean and being sound proof was the best."

"Everything was great. Very quiet."

"This cottage is my new "home away from home"!! Everything was better than what you see in the pictures. The peacefulness and privacy of the area made me feel so relaxed. Morning coffee in the rocking chair on the porch while listening to the birds chirp set the mood for each day. Location to Amish / local establishments was easy to navigate once you know the area. Melissa was quick to respond to any needs, yet very respectful of my wish for independence. I have - and will continue to highly recommend this cottage for a destination near Sugar Creek or New Philadephia, Ohio"