Holiday Homes in Shelter Island

"The place was exactly as expected and advertised. A nice place to relax at the end of the day with everything you need to rest and recover. Absolutely lovely location and just an overall great place to get away for a weekend"

"Lovely quaint home. Very clean and spacious. Perfect for a family getaway . Highly recommend."

"Wonderful home in a gorgeous area. The house was updated beautifully and clean, spacious deck and the pool was great. We really loved our time there and would stay again! Host was responsive and easy to work with as well :)"

"House was very nice. Location is great. Easy walk to beach and convenient to Westbrook center."

"Our overall expertise was great. Home was very clean and had all the essentials you need for a nice comfortable stay. The beds were very comfy, equipped with great linens and pillows. Home was cozy and comfortable. Can’t wait to stay again."

"The house was great. Super comfortable and the backyard is wonderful with a gas fireplace, a fire pit, a hot tub, a pool, and an outdoor grill setup. There were 7 of us any it was very comfortable. Dave was great and very prompt and helpful if we needed anything. Would definitely come back."

"Spacious comfortable and inviting home. Well-stocked everything. Lovely outdoor spaces and gracious hosts."

"Great pet friendly property in Amagansett! Best feature of the the house has to be the backyard. Large deck around swimming pool, with built-in grill, pergola. The property is completely gated (included a gated entrance) and in a very quite neighborhood. Easy access to shopping and restaurants in Amagansett and short drive to Montauk. Property being managed by StayMarquis was a plus as they were very responsive and met us at the property upon arrival. Finding the house is challenging as Google...

"Beautifully decorated comfortable and clean would definitely rent again"

"From the minute I stepped on the property and then went inside, I fell in Love! So tranquil and peaceful, yet you can drive 10 minutes into the heart of it all and experience the reasons East Hampton’s is well known for, and then some! I have never been to a vacation home where I didn’t have to scrub down, clean and or have to pack everything I needed because it was ALL there. The attention to every detail .. I thank Rick for that and he was exceptionally responsive! ( this is my first booking...

"Property is well kept and clean, pool and hot tub were both in well working condition! Plenty of entertainment for the kids and appreciated the plentiful dishware and cooking utensils for big family meals. Owner of the home was very responsive and answered all of our questions. Only call out is I wish the shipyard playground in the backyard was better maintained. The slide covered in spiderwebs and needed to be cleaned."

"my family and i grew up coming to hampton bays - and while myself and my parents have moved away - a family wedding brought us back to the area and we were so happy to stay local in this perfect home. it felt great to be back in the old neighborhood and not have to be cramped at my brothers home just a short 5 minute drive away. i hope we can stay again during our next trip!"

"The cottage was perfect for us. Beautiful location, easy access to the beach. Beds are very comfortable. Spacious and the sunroom is a wonderful place to sit and relax. My sisters and I thoroughly enjoyed everything about the area. The locals are welcoming and will provide you with great information about the area. Mystic aquarium is within 20 minutes and a great place to visit. There are a multitude of great restaurants to try out and fresh fish markets if you want to grill out in the back...

"Great house with everything you need for a fun weekend. Enjoyed the kayaks, deck, view, birds and surrounding area. Host was very welcoming and accommodating."

"older cottage style well maintained great area"

"Great property. Great owner."

"It was a cute cottage, nicely decorated. We were very comfortable. Each bedroom had a private bathroom which was very nice. It was close to downtown Southampton so that was great. The owner checked in and was very helpful. "