Our group consisted of my husband and I, our 18month old, my parents, and his parents.
The good - The view as advertised was the primary reason we chose this cabin, and it did not disappoint - truly amazing. You do drive up some small, winding, steep roads to get there, but it is doable. Worth mentioning that one of our vehicles had difficulty getting up the hill when wet. The cabin offers plenty of space and having 4 bedrooms with king beds was a definite plus, though if you are looking for truly equivalent bed/baths for 4 couples the ones upstairs are not as nice (bad carpet and tiny showers) as the ones on the bottom and main levels (newer carpet and nicer bathrooms). The kitchen is very well equipped and has pretty much everything we could want.
The bad: It was really dirty when we checked in. There were crumbs under the kitchen table, hair on bathroom counters. The shower stalls in the upstairs bathrooms are very small and the curtains were covered in mold. The smell was overwhelming when we entered the shower and then we had to shower in a tiny space trying not to touch anything. While the sheets were of very nice quality, there was a stain on a pillowcase in our bedroom that I am pretty sure was blood. Will also mention that while the bottom and main floors have very nice flooring, the carpet upstairs appears quite old and just seems dirty/dingy in general. My mom and mother-in-law both let me know that their bathrooms were quite dirty as well. I let the owner/manager know about the condition of the cabin early on in our stay, in part because I wanted him to know and in part because I did not want to be charged for the stained pillowcase (there are many signs throughout the cabin letting guests know that if they damage the linens they will be charged for them). In addition to requesting pictures (which I did spend vacation time providing), he said, "I will send the cleaners back to replace and reckless if you want." I'm not sure what that meant, but if it was an offer to clean the cabin, we really didn't want the cleaners we had just complained about in the cabin while we were there. He also stated that the shower curtains were usually washed (I really doubt they had been washed in months), but since it was a same day turnover, they probably didn't have time. Our cleaning fee was not refunded and he did not even apologize for the condition of the cabin.