Top Hotels Near Matecumbe United Methodist Church in Islamorada from NZ$256

"Room was nice with balcony but not what I expected. Thought I was booking the room that was in the picture. All the pictures of my room at time of reservation appeared like the photos shown on the site, but this was not in fact the room we received. Overall the property is pretty nice with bikes, kayaks and paddleboards available at no extra charge. There was a free shuttle to the sister resorts Amara Cay and Three Waters Resorts. We went to the Three Waters Resort and this resort was a bit nicer than La Siesta and the staff there was amazing. The staff a La Siesta, not so much often hard to find, even at the pool bar and beach/kayak area."

"Beautiful property. Best part is it’s very pet friendly. Will be back very soon"

"Highly recommend La Jolla .. it is a gem of the Keys. "

"Great, will recommend"

"Room was clean .some of the staff was really rude. The staff out by paddle board were never around. Better off staying at Three Waters resort . Staff much more accommodating . Nicer and it the sister resort to Amara Cay."

"Really impressed with this property. "

"Lovely little hotel, walking distance to a couple of bars and restaurants for a bayside sunset. Free parking, friendly staff, great pool area. Only negatives was the air con was very noisy and any rooms on the ground floor are a little dark. But overall we had a fab stay and well worth the money."

"The place was perfect for our family. I wish that the closet space could have been utilized and the drawers in the dressers, were not all available for use. We did notice that the A/C unit in the Tarpon house was not cooling very well.. In the afternoons the indoor temp would climb to 80, instead of the 73 it was set for. Also, if we could have found a broom, we could have kept the floors cleaner."

"Exelente service but the room need more clean and attention "