Top Hotels Near Gardiner's Bay Country Club in Shelter Island from NZ$356

"Room could use some maintenance like the bathroom and more outlets. Staff was friendly "

"Bill is a wonderful and knowledgeable host for a beautiful getaway in a unique setting."

"We made our reservation paid the bill we got to the hotel they told us you have to pay $29 a night to park your car in the hotel parking lot. WE WERE NEVER INFORMED OF THIS!! I have my reservation to prove it!!!"

"Great accommodation for our family of 4. Extended family rented next door. We were in town for a wedding and house was close to everything. Check in and communication were excellent. House was very clean and we enjoyed our stay. Was nice to be able to walk into town for meals and shopping. Would definitely recommend. Thank you!"

"They charged us for parking in front of our room. Unbelievable. We stayed there in April, off season, the motel was empty."

"Great stay & great staff!"

"The property was gorgeous…brand new. Great location to the center of town including the carousel, Aldo’s coffee shop, and great bars/restaurants. The staff went above and beyond beyond! The bar was great…excellent cocktails, prestigious service, and FUN games to play too. A must stay for anyone going to Greenport! "

"This was my second stay at this house, and it was just as wonderful as my first stay back in 2019. The house is large and can sleep many people comfortably. The kitchen had all the necessary amenities, and there was plenty of room to hang out and eat. Al was extremely communicative and made the check-in process easy. The house is charming, and quirky, and the perfect price-point for what my group needed for a stay in the Greenport area. I hope to return in the near future!"

"We had a great time staying here - Chris’s place was clean, comfortable and perfect location for exploring Greenport. We loved being able to walk so easily to all the shops and restaurants. Would definitely stay here again!"