Top Hotels Near Blue Hole in Big Pine Key from NZ$397

"First room was poor. Changed to another but cost me $100 per day more. Floor was dirty so I cleaned it. Breakfast was fair. Pool was good."

"Didn’t have a cleaning sponge, otherwise was great!"

"We (4 older adults) enjoyed our stay. The property is situated at the corner of a canal with only one abutting neighbor. It was delightfully peaceful and quiet. We enjoyed many shady hours under the tiki. Once the pool heat was adjusted, we enjoyed a dip every afternoon. There was a problem with the plumbing, but that was taken care of promptly. The plumber was excellent as was the pool man. Our host was very responsive to every request and query. We enjoyed seeing the key deer wandering around the roads and yards. The electric gate keeps most of them out of the yard. "

"We recently spent the month of February at Castaway on the Keys and the property is wonderful. The house is bright, spacious and well equipped. The beds are comfortable and the bathrooms are great. The entire house is clean and well maintained. The outside area is resort-like, with a heated pool, plenty of pool chairs, and great water front views. The upper and lower deck/patio areas are large and provide ample space for lounging, with two gas grills, ice machine and sink. We have spent a month in the Keys for the past six years, each in a different house in a different Key, and this is our favorite property - by far. The communication with the property's agent, iTrip, was timely and informative."

"We had a wonderful stay February 2026! Absolute gem property on Big Pine. Gorgeous property, spacious home, HUGE pool, relaxing peaceful spot in paradise. Everything you need for a great getaway. Great communication with owners who keep this place well maintained. Already booked our stay for next year!"

"My husband, dog and myself stayed for a month and really enjoyed this house. Lovely touches include a plush robe, steamer, soaps and shampoo, blow dryer etc. Lots of extra linens, towels. Well-stocked kitchen, including 2 coffee makers, keurig coffee pods and regular coffee. Frig had filtered water and ice. Every weekend is a flea market and we got some great buys there. The Keys is very pet friendly and many bars and restaurants are pet-friendly. Host was very responsive . "

"It was a great stay!"

"We absolutely enjoyed our stay at Big Pine Paradise. We come down for a month every year and this was the first time we stayed here but it for sure will not be our last. The location making it easy to get to the back country or ocean side, the marina with boat launch and dockside fuel just around the corner, the pool to cool off in after a day on the water. An absolutely beautiful home and great management as well, anything we needed was easy to get answers or help. Thank you for such an awesome stay!"

"Frigate’s Nest was a great place to stay at while in the Keys. Separate houses made it nice to have families have their own space while still being steps away from each other. Houses were in great shape and clean with bathrooms for each room. Place was secluded and had dock on the gulf. We had a great time for mini season! Would definitely rebook and comeback!"