Top Hotels Near Vineyard Playhouse in Vineyard Haven from NZ$303

"Excellent stay at the Mansion Inn. Clean property and wonderful staff. We will be back!"

"Everything is excellent in the lobby, loved the decor and seating areas. Staff was helpful with bags and quickly changing our room location from the 4th to 2nd floor. Wonderful staff, invited us in with a smile. Birthday decorations were nicely done and appreciated. The only negative is not setup for seniors. We had to carry our bags up the steps to the lobby."

"Cozy Timber Retreat - Ideal for Couples, Solo Travelers and Small Families. This charming cottage was the perfect sanctuary for a peaceful escape. Though modest in footprint, the dramatic lofted ceilings created a sense of spaciousness that was truly remarkable. Crafted entirely from timber, the home radiated rustic elegance and warmth in every corner. The space was very clean and beautifully maintained with a thoughtfully equipped kitchen featuring high-end cookware that made dining in a genuine pleasure. The cottage was also conveniently located near local markets (can highly recommend NorthTisbury Farmer's Market), Vineyard Haven, Oak Bluffs, and other delightful island spots - making it easy to explore while still enjoying the peace and quiet of a tucked-away retreat. We were lucky enough to spot wild turkeys wandering nearby, adding a touch of whimsy and wildlife charm to our days. The hosts - who live close by - struck the perfect balance: completely respectful of our privacy while also being warm and delightful to interact with. It had been quite a few years since I'd last visited Martha's Vineyard, and this stay rekindled something deep for me. I feel reconnected with the island's beauty, its quiet spirit - and honestly, I did not want to leave. Whether you're seeking connection, romance, solitude, or shared memories with friends and/or family, this special cottage offers a restorative experience that will linger long after you return. Highly recommended!"

"The hotel owner or manager was very welcoming and explained a bit about the area. Thanks for a great stay and location! "

"cottage is like new. small but perfectly anointed. great location to Vineyard Haven. Mike is great landlord!"

"Super clean, beautifully decorated, mostly renovated. Had absolutely everything you could possibly need. "

"The house was well stocked and had everything you could need. "

"The property is just amazing and the owner was incredibly helpful and easy to communicate with. Location can’t be beat. Highly recommend for anyone wanting to stay in Tisbury and/or in the water. "

"Great "