Top Hotels Near Sunset Beach in Shelter Island Heights from NZ$198

"The host was very understanding about some last minute events that affected our trip"

"Room was great. Clean and comfortable. Glad I found this place and will be back. "

"The staff was wonderful and the room and views fantastic."

"Amazing room and view from the room was perfect! "

"Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :). "

"Quiet yet situated right in the heart of Greenport."

"This place was a dream. Super comfortable. The host has thought of everything, including a sweet holiday welcome gift. Everything is in walking distance- I didn't use my car for 2 days. It was wonderful to walk along the water into town. What a great retreat! "

"Everything was excellent, best hotel on the north fork. "

"The House on Chase Creek is absolutely amazing! My husband and I are celebrating our 20th anniversary and I’ve been telling him about Shelter Island literally for almost 40 years. Well we finally made it and the trip, the home, the welcoming of my dog, was all so just so welcoming and nice. Bill, the proprietor, took great care to answer any questions and tell us about the Island. Then we enter the most immaculate room, as clean as the ritz! I mean it…I broke a glass by my nightstand and had to move the stand to clean up the glass; when I say not one speck of dust, not one fuzz bunny, so clean you could eat off the floor, even under the bed!! We enjoyed our stay so much we extended our trip and Bill, was extremely helpful, and welcomed us to stay longer! We can’t wait to go back, and we are going to try and make it an annual event. Thank you Bill for all your kindness and see you soon!!! MA and Erich Schmalhorst. PS. The bed AMAZING, sleep so peaceful, I can’t express how wonderful this place is to stay in. I almost want to erase this review because I don’t want to let the “cat out of the bag”!"