Top Hotels Near Sugarloaf Beach in Summerland Key from NZ$401

"Our stay at this property was amazing! Staff is kind and courteous and tend to our needs. Room was clean and had all we need it to make light breakfast and lunch and dinner if need it. "

"good location"

"The pictures we received at the time we rented this property were grossly misrepresented.We were told it was a gated property. When we pulled up, the gate waa wide open..it did not work at all.The main door to enter the house locked; however, there were two other doors that were wide open when we entered as the locks were broken.It is advertised as having a hot tub and heated pool. When we arrived, we were informed it was not a hot tub but a spillover into the pool. The thermostat on the pool said 104, but the water temperature waa 70 degrees.The outside of the property has been poorly taken care of. Broken chairs near the pool, mildew buildup on the fence, trash everywhere, and black mold on the "extra" apartment on the property. The house is advertised to sleep 10 and said the couch opened up into a bed. The couch does not open up. There werent even 10 chairs to sit on or 10 forks to eat from.We would not stay here again."

"We had a wonderful time the end of February 2026 at tropical paradise. The outdoor space and views were incredible. We were able to see some fish and and a resident iguana. The indoor space is nice, but could use some updates and a really good cleaning. The kitchen could use some additional cooking utensils and there were no potholders and only one hand towel. We ended up using bath towels. The beds were very comfortable. We were able to feel like we were alone even with houses close by. It was very secluded feeling."

"Thank you, Adrian, for being a great host and helping to make our month-long stay special. The well-equipped kitchen with cookware, utensils, spices and oils made cooking in easy with everything needed at hand. The spacious main living area adjacent to the kitchen was great for family gatherings. And the jumbo TV was a bonus we all enjoyed. The house was clean, beds comfy, and updated bathrooms appreciated. The downstairs living area was great as we all had space to unwind without feeling cramped. The stunning view and sunsets were enjoyed in the private, resort-like setting. The kayaks and paddle boards were used and enjoyed. The pool was wonderful for cooling off and relaxing. Sharing the place with family was special as we all have great memories! We'll be back! "

"We rented this property through Vacasa/VRBO for a family celebration with our three adult children and their partners. Our plans were to spend several days hanging out and catching up. For a party of eight, this home served us perfectly. This home is secluded on a beautifully landscaped parcel; just a 20-minute drive from Key West. The bottom level has been converted into a veranda with multiple seating and dining areas on travertine flooring that looks onto an infinity pool with a hot tub. Beyond the pool, there is a small sandy beach looking onto a sound that is perfect for kayaking, watching sunsets and stargazing. The home is large and well appointed with four bedrooms, each with its own ensuite, full bath and television The kitchen is large and modern. The garage has been converted into a game room and arcade. Surrounding the home is a covered open porch with multiple options for seating and gathering. We loved this house. It was clean, bright and open, and worked out perfectly for our family reunion. Overall rating 9.5/10."

"Beautiful location. House was very nice and backyard was awesome. "

"Beautiful! Pool was amazing!"

"The Online Property Manager almost pushed us to ask for a refund by telling us about loud dock construction between the hours of 10am -2pm every day immediately after he secured our final payment for the trip. Thankfully Tom who is the onsite manager was amazing and had the construction stopped for the duration of our stay. He gave us endless local knowledge, help, and let us borrow a cooler and some of his personal equipment. Everything was clean and wonderful on the property and it was stocked with fun amenities.The trip would be perfect if not for the sargassum which made the first 4-5 feet of the water rather foul but after that it was amazing to kayak or paddleboard on. If we revisit we will definitely go earlier when there is less of the sargassum, as well as hopefully a completed new dock that should be great for swimming and avoiding the sargassum altogether. Overral the food in the keys, the house, the views, and the wonderful host Tom made this trip a wonderful get away. "