Book a Shelter Island Cottage

"The room was spacious. I’m very clean. I was very impressed. Location easy to get in and out of highly recommend."

"poor breakfast, air conditioning was ok"

"This hotel was lovely. I enjoyed the decor, how spacious it was, the lawn and the couches to sit in outside. Truly, an amazing experience in every way. The staff was always welcoming and helpful. No complaints and I would definitely stay again if I come to the Hamptons! "

"Perfect! Welcoming, clean & close to everything. "

"The kitchen was perfect, only thing missing was utensils. There is a local store on the way to the manor to pick some of those staples up from. "

"Lovely place for a quiet getaway off-season. Loved this place and will be back. Only disappointment was morning coffee … lacking flavor and lukewarm … but there is a wonderful shop just a few doors down with very good coffee. Nespresso machine in room. "

"Front desk staff were amazing! The bar staff were very attentive and friendly. Rooms are clean, but definitely dated."

"Loved our stay. Our room was gorgeous a s in the perfect location. Would recommend and plan on coming back in the future!"

"Very nice rooms! Clean and the location is great! "