Lodging Image

Book a Shelter Island Cottage

  • Change your mind

    Book hotels with free cancellation

  • Treat yourself

    Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
    Sign in

  • Be picky

    Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks
30 Oct - 1 Nov
In two months
11 Dec - 13 Dec
In three months
8 Jan - 10 Jan
In four months
5 Feb - 7 Feb

Our top choices for Shelter Island cottages

A rustic cabin with a wooden exterior, a front porch, and a staircase leading to the entrance.

1. North Fork Resort

North Fork Resort
3.0 star property
Greenport
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (65 reviews)
"Friendly staff. Clean room had everything we needed. Enjoyed our stay!"
United States
Harold
The price is NZ$494
includes taxes & fees
18 Oct - 19 Oct
North Fork Resort
A deck with a gray sofa, a wooden chair, and a metal fire pit.

2. The Greenport Beach Cottage: 3 Min Walk to Beach, 1 mile to Town

The Greenport Beach Cottage: 3 Min Walk to Beach, 1 mile to Town
Greenport
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
"Wonderful house. Immaculate with all the provisions you can hope for. Perfect location and beautifully done!"
United States
Jeannette M.
The price is NZ$1,619
includes taxes & fees
19 Oct - 20 Oct
The Greenport Beach Cottage: 3 Min Walk to Beach, 1 mile to Town
A small single-story house with a front porch, a potted plant, and two Adirondack chairs.

3. 1-bedroom cottage with Grove Beach 🏖️ access.

1-bedroom cottage with Grove Beach 🏖️ access.
Clinton
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (61 reviews)
"We enjoyed our stay"
United States
JM B.
The price is NZ$370
includes taxes & fees
21 Oct - 22 Oct
1-bedroom cottage with Grove Beach 🏖️ access.
A residential area with houses, a driveway, and a body of water in the background.

4. Steps to the beach | Seabreeze Cottage #3

Steps to the beach | Seabreeze Cottage #3
Hampton Bays
6.0 out of 10, (3 reviews)
"The property needs a major cleaning and repairs. The floors were sticky, and the carpet was dirty. Furniture was dirty and soiled. There was dried food on the utensils. The pipes groaned at all hours, several times an hour. The bed creaked with every movement. Bedroom blinds were broken and wouldn’t close all the way. The bedside lamp on the wall was falling off. The last straw was the huge spider that jumped down from the closet onto me. We ended up leaving after less than 24 hours and...
United States
Lydia
The price is NZ$867
includes taxes & fees
1 Nov - 2 Nov
Steps to the beach | Seabreeze Cottage #3
A single-story house with a gabled roof, a front porch, and a well-maintained garden.

5. Walk to Beach | Seabreeze Cottage #4

Walk to Beach | Seabreeze Cottage #4
Hampton Bays
8.6 out of 10, Excellent, (8 reviews)
"Great stay. Would stay again. "
United States
Weston B.
The price is NZ$795
includes taxes & fees
18 Oct - 19 Oct
Walk to Beach | Seabreeze Cottage #4
A white cottage with a front door, a garage, and a small porch with a potted plant.

6. The gardners Cottage 1 mile from long Island Sound - pet friendly

The gardners Cottage 1 mile from long Island Sound - pet friendly
Clinton
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (29 reviews)
"Enjoyed our stay - Highly recommend!"
United States
Mary S.
The price is NZ$526
includes taxes & fees
18 Oct - 19 Oct
The gardners Cottage 1 mile from long Island Sound - pet friendly
A living room with a sofa, armchair, coffee table, and a television.

7. Westbrook Getaway-Near Beaches, Train & Shoreline

Westbrook Getaway-Near Beaches, Train & Shoreline
Westbrook Center
The price is NZ$606
includes taxes & fees
20 Oct - 21 Oct
Westbrook Getaway-Near Beaches, Train & Shoreline
A two-story house with a porch, a mailbox, and a lawn.

8. Welcoming 1-Bedroom Cottage in Charming Madison is One Mile to Town and Beach!

Welcoming 1-Bedroom Cottage in Charming Madison is One Mile to Town and Beach!
Madison
9.4 out of 10, Exceptional, (3 reviews)
"Cozy cottage was perfect for our long weekend in Madison!"
United States
Samantha D.
The price is NZ$627
includes taxes & fees
20 Oct - 21 Oct
Welcoming 1-Bedroom Cottage in Charming Madison is One Mile to Town and Beach!
A small, single-story house with a white porch and a wooden front door.

9. Cozy Renovated Cottage with Game Room, WiFi, AC - Mins to Beach & Boardwalk

Cozy Renovated Cottage with Game Room, WiFi, AC - Mins to Beach & Boardwalk
Waterford
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (34 reviews)
"The stay was great and the host was more than kind and very helpful! "
United States
Jenna K.
The price is NZ$690
includes taxes & fees
20 Oct - 21 Oct
Cozy Renovated Cottage with Game Room, WiFi, AC - Mins to Beach & Boardwalk
Terrace/patio

10. 5th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork

5th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
Aquebogue
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (3 reviews)
"Fantastic experience. Cabin was clean and quiet. Beautiful mornings on the water."
United States
Leah O.
The price is NZ$1,570
includes taxes & fees
18 Oct - 19 Oct
5th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
A sign for J&S Reeves Cottages with a view of a house and trees.

11. 4th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork

4th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
Aquebogue
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (19 reviews)
"Great cottage on amazing grounds! We loved the screened in porch. Sandy and john are great hosts. We also loved using the kayaks and checking out the bay."
United States
Richard C.
The price is NZ$1,599
includes taxes & fees
18 Oct - 19 Oct
4th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
A sign for J&S Reeves Cottages with a view of a house and trees.

12. 3rd of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork

3rd of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
Aquebogue
8.6 out of 10, Excellent, (7 reviews)
"We loved everything about our stay at the cottage. Such beautiful property and surroundings. If you’re looking to spend some quality time with family in a quiet setting with beautiful surroundings , look no further. Thanks Sandy. We will be Back."
United States
Wendy B.
The price is NZ$1,740
includes taxes & fees
18 Oct - 19 Oct
3rd of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
A sign for J&S Reeves Cottages with a view of a house and trees.

13. 6th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork

6th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
Riverhead
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (12 reviews)
"We enjoyed our stay. Very quiet and relaxing. Excellent location to many wineries. Would definitely stay again."
United States
Donna M.
6th of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
A lakeside cottage with a covered porch, a sign for J&S Reeves Cottages, and a grassy lawn with lounge chairs.

14. 1st of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork

1st of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
Aquebogue
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (7 reviews)
"Nice scenery. Spartan kitchen furnishings and bathroom toiletries. Paid booking (including all ocuppants and pets) and was invoiced by vrbo. Received addtional invoice from the owner adding 250 dolars pet fee (125x2 pets) which was not listed on the property description that only mentions "pet friendly"."
United States
Simon C.
The price is NZ$1,740
includes taxes & fees
20 Oct - 21 Oct
1st of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
A waterfront property with a grassy lawn, a dock with boats, and a patio area with outdoor furniture.

15. 2nd of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork

2nd of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
Aquebogue
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (5 reviews)
"Great rental experience. Owners friendly and available"
United States
Patricia and Michael F.
The price is NZ$1,740
includes taxes & fees
20 Oct - 21 Oct
2nd of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
View all properties
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Sign in
Sign up, it's free

Top Shelter Island Hotel Reviews

Zey Hotel

Zey Hotel

10/10 Excellent
"It worked out well for me."
Elizabeth 1-night trip
Posted 6 hours ago
Zey Hotel

Find out more about Shelter Island

Shelter Island Cottages information

Number of reviews
131
Accommodation
222 Cottages
Lowest Price
NZ$370
Highest Price
NZ$1,740