Settlers Landing Hotels, Barnegat

"Room was clean and hotel very nice. Pool and hot tub were great! "

"We stayed after a wedding in Toms River on 3/21/26. The place was packed with other weddings with kids in attendance. The hotel was just ok, needs a major update. We were able to get back to the hotel and ‘try’ to sleep. The hallways were very noisy. And it sounded like kids running up and down the Hallways, they were very loud with people running up and down. We needed to check out of the hotel by 11am, so once we were able to get a little sleep, we were soon woken up for checkout and on our way to AC Airport. We were scrambling, throwing our suit case together to be able to be out on time and off to the airport. I wouldn’t recommend this hotel to anyone that needs to get a good nights sleep."

"Minimal breakfast choices but they were good."

"I only came for one day while needing some quiet time to get work done, so I can’t speak to some of the negative reviews I’ve seen online, but I had a decent experience. The staff was cordial, the room was clean, and I liked my little patio area that faced the courtyard. The hotel shares space with a pub/restaurant, but it wasn’t rowdy or sketchy during my stay and I didn’t feel unsafe at all. (Then again, I’m from NYC 😛)"

"Very clean and very friendly staff! "

"It was great"

"Comfort Please keep the noice down after 10pm. Breakfast It would be better that the breakfast starts around 8am. Thank you very much!"

"The worse place to stay. Very old and run down. The pictures online are very deceiving. The place was a dump. Got locked in the bathroom at 4:30am. Had to call in the maintenance guy to drill out the door knob to get out. Was trapped for 1.5 hours. Left and never stayed our second night. To much of a dump."

"This hotel is awesome! Thank you for everything!"