Search Guest Houses in Put-in-Bay

"We always love staying at castaway Bay. A few disappointments this time. It seems they opened and closed a lot of the slides. We went to get ice cream on Saturday night and they were out of almost every topping. They said they were out of sprinkles but I saw a box there on the counter. I think they just didn't want to open the new box because it was the end of the evening. There's not a lot of other options so they should cater until the end of the day. "

"Everything is good about this hotel "

"😉"

"Clean room, clean facilities, friendly staff, main restaurant had good food at a reasonable price, plenty of kid friendly events all day. It felt like an escape from the cold weather. I thought it was a great value for the money. "

"No issues. Clean and comfortable "

"Spiders and webs on the ceiling and strong cleaning smell in the first room. "

"Half of the staff was nice. "

"This place was amazing! All we could ask for, plus such a close walk to downtown area! Owners answered all questions I had"

"Location was perfect! Everything was comfortable and convenient. The beds and furniture were very comfortable and clean. The only complaints we had was the sound of the water pump. Any time water is running it is so loud! Especially annoying in the bedrooms in the mornings. Small trade off for the comfort and convenience of the home! I would still HIGHLY recommend this place to anyone! Especially during the peak season! (I do not recommend a stay in October!!! Most stuff was closed or not following their posted times for business. Very disappointed in that portion of our visit.) Our host and our home, however, was phenomenal! Thank you for another amazing trip! "