Search Guest Houses in Montauk

"Highly recommend. In the middle of everything old harbor!"

"Excellent location and adorable character! Second stay here and can’t wait to come back!"

"Such a cute place to stay! Bill was super kind and helpful! I was only in for a quick night but I would definitely stay here again!!"

"We had a wonderful stay and had everything we needed. Location was wonderful, everything was spotless, bed was very comfy, bathroom was great, and we didn't know it, but we got a surprise porch off our room facing the harbor. Kai, the owner, was in touch and made our stay even more comfortable offering us a car rental when the rest of town was sold out. I recommend the Inn at Old Harbor highly and will absolutely be staying again,"

"Of all of the places I have stayed in, this was hands down my favorite! From the stunning view to the beautifully designed interior, I was in awe of this carriage home. It had everything I needed and more, with thoughtful touches like beach chairs, a cooler and umbrellas to use. Everything was so comfortable and I really appreciated the blackout shades in the bedroom. I will be looking for excuses to visit here again and again!"

"Great location, friendly staff"