Book a Marsh Harbour Cottage

"It looked like all the rooms have a clear view of the sea and marina. This hotel is in need of a good refurbishment. The main pool , bar and place to eat are a walk away from the rooms. Not in the main building. On the positive side The staff are great but it’s overpriced for it’s current condition "

"Terrific Villa. Everything worked as advertised. We really liked that the patio has a nice new dining table with umbrella and has some nice vegetation and shrubbery that provides a lot more privacy that many of the villas. The beach here is unbeatable. Many days there were less than 50 people on the 3 miles stretch of paradise. The sand is like sugar. Brian is a great host and very responsive to questions. He also provided a lot of info on the area before the trip. 5 STARS! "

"Was a life saver last night: Clean/ quick/ convenient "

"Excellent!"

"Spectacular staff. Wonderful location. Great property. We will be back!"

"March 11-16, 2026. Absolutely a rental you won’t want to miss. As you approach the property and as you walk in you can tell the owners have spent lots of time thinking of everything. The house and the property are truly amazing. Very will equipped. We had everything we needed the whole time there. There was nothing but groceries needed to cook meals. I would highly recommend this property to anyone. I will return again as well. Even my kids and their significant others are planning a trip to experience this property. The neighbors are friendly. So many turtles. Shells daily along the beaches. Although many in the guest book had mentioned seeing rays we never spotted any. The cabana by the beach was a nice place to hangout during the day for relief from the sun while laying in the hammock and feeling the breezes. I was in contact with the owners and they are caring and friendly too. I’m already looking forward to booking this property again and again in the future. Tim ShookNew Braunfels, TX"

"Perfect Treasure Cay Home! Close to beach, nice pool."

"Good location. Island is rebuilding like new. "

"The place was well appointed & very comfy. We cooked breakfast & dinner every day in the kitchen. Although it was quite windy & rough, we rented kayaks & explored the beaches, getting great rides on the waves on our downwind legs. Maria is a very responsive host. The house was clean as a whistle thanks to Linda. Lovely, welcoming community with an amazing heated, well-kept pool. Will definitely be back. Treasure Cay is the prettiest beach ever. "