Top Hotels Near Eleutheros Cooke House and Garden in Sandusky from NZ$111

"We always love staying at castaway Bay. A few disappointments this time. It seems they opened and closed a lot of the slides. We went to get ice cream on Saturday night and they were out of almost every topping. They said they were out of sprinkles but I saw a box there on the counter. I think they just didn't want to open the new box because it was the end of the evening. There's not a lot of other options so they should cater until the end of the day. "

"Overall great stay. Very accommodating to our family. Really enjoyed the smal attention to detail. "

"This place was and had everything we needed for a comfortable stay! We are back in a few weeks and I can’t wait "

"The beauty and uniqueness of the house, the amount and quality of the amenities, and the ease of contacting the host."

"No issues. Clean and comfortable "

"The room was terrible. Writing kept on appearing in the top left of the tv screen every 20 or 30 seconds and that beat the purpose of even watching tv. The heat didn’t work really well and the water pressure was really bad. Would never stay here again☹️☹️"

"Overall not bad, but not great. The house was mostly clean, but the fans and air vents could definitely use a dusting. The shower drain was very slow, so you end up standing in water. The drive way is very narrow, even for a small SUV. The neighborhood is ok, although we did get to listen to the neighbors car alarm for several hours in the middle of the night.There was no communication with the host, not that we needed anything, but no welcome or check in messages. The thing that really bugged me was a prior bad review where the host commented that the guests accidentally went into the neighbors house. Unless the neighbors house has the exact same furniture and rug, the pictures they posted were definitely of this house.The house is very big, and we enjoyed the space. It was good for a trip to Cedar Point with extended family. We were not dissatisfied, but also not really impressed."

"Cute place, decorated with a “lake” vacay theme. Bedrooms are small, though; had to store luggage in the kitchen. Also had to run out and buy ice cube trays! Coffee maker with coffee was handy. Finally, could hear voices upstairs, which was weird. "

"The house was great! Had everything we needed and slept all 9 of our group very comfortably. Very close to Cedar Point. Host was prompt with replies. We hope to stay here again next year. "