Book Rum Cay Hotels
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Top Rum Cay Hotel Reviews
Beachfront family home steps from the perfect secluded ocean beach.
10/10 Excellent
"John and Cassandra's place is exactly what we were looking for. The second we walked in, it was clear this was a home, not a rental. Every room had its own personality, quaint, charming, and you knew you were in a place that was loved. The ocean view was unreal and the beach was literally right outside the door.Communication was seamless and John, Cassandra, and their house manager David were a pleasure to deal with. No hassle, no chasing anyone down. Just amazing people who take care of their guests. Do yourself a favor and book this place."
The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks
10/10 Excellent
"2nd stay at the gate house and everything was perfect. The house has everything you need for a private relaxing stay. Will definitely return."
Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views
10/10 Excellent
"I fell in love with Cat Island.Stephanie the owner replies to messages if you contact her. Very helpful with my questionsHarrison the care taker did a very good job of taking care of us, and he is also a very good cook. The first night we ordered him some food omg all the food was yummy and fresh, and take note the greens are from his garden! And we did another night order of lobster, it didnot disappoint! The lobster was fresh and its big one too! And i love talking to Harrison. He is a good man. Bless this man.Overall stay was a blast! Cant complain. Just watch for mosquito and the small insect "no-sse-um" its nature cant control them Lol! "
Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove
10/10 Excellent
"Baywatch Cottage – Long Island, Bahamas April 2–10An outstanding stay from start to finish. Debbie and Phillip are exceptional hosts. They met us at Stella Maris Airport and escorted us directly to the cottage. Cozy, comfortable, and right on the bay, Baywatch delivers exactly what you're looking for if you want to unplug and recharge.Long Island itself is a gem. Up north: the Columbus Monument, the stunning beach at Cape Santa Maria, and rum punches with Shawn at the Busted Bridge. Down south: Gordon's Settlement, another gorgeous white-sand beach with turquoise water, and great conversation (and rum punches) with Earnest, who knows this island inside and out. In between, don't miss Dean's Blue Hole, the Shrimp Hole, and stops at the Vantage Point (ask for Ash), Dapple, Tiny's, Chez Pierre (excellent meal), Harbour Club, Sou' Side, and Letta's.Bahama Mama Debbie and Phillip will take great care of you. Highly recommend."
The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks
10/10 Excellent
"After our recent vacation at the Point House, I can honestly say that this was the most well designed and beautiful house we have ever stayed in. The pool is beyond fantastic and a great place to wind down after days filled with sightseeing and flyfishing. The extensive decks are great too with panoramic views of sunsets and sea life along the coral heads. Harrison King, the caretaker, was very congenial and knowledgeable about the history of Cat Island. He brought dinner the first night and we ate for days - EXCELLENT!!! Lots of sights and side activities - beaches, flats, blue holes, wildlife, Healing Pond, restaurants and fun places to get a drink and soak up the sun. I definitely recommend the Point House for families and anyone who wants to enjoy a truly luxury home in a gorgeous setting on Cat Island. We will return!!!"
New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?
10/10 Excellent
"Amazing stay loved walking right out on to the beach. We saw rays, sharks, starfish and lots of fish right out the back door. Karin the house manager was wonderful and even did some shopping for us before we arrived. She also was able to get us a highchair and pack and play for our 1 year old. "
Stella Maris Resort Club
8/10 Good
"Our room was very clean with a lovely view towards the sea. We really enjoyed the Moonshine Bar where the food and drink was spot on and we enjoyed watching the sea and walking on the shore. There are hammocks and a few loungers available also. The main building is comfortable and nicely set out. it was super quiet when we were there which was lovely, the only downside being the bar and food service stopped at 6.30m which is very early. "
The Sands Hotel
2/10 Terrible
"False advertisement on Hotels.com. Pool was not working. Beach was not as pictured due to hurricane. Front desk was very unfriendly. Forced us to eat our dinner in the room instead of dining room and then charged us double for dinner. Bar staff ignored us and charged us double the locals. Locals took over the bar. Nothing was open except the Club Med down the road. We do not see any reason to return to San Salvador."
White Ocean Coral - Private Beach Villa
2/10 Terrible
"DO NOT RENT THIS PROPERTY. Nothing matches the listing—dirty, trashy yard, broken oven, no advertised BBQ, two broken TVs, broken door locks, dilapidated/unsafe deck, broken deck chairs, rusted utensils, moldy sponges, corroded fixtures, soiled bedsheets and towels, no bright pillows or rugs as shown in the photos, no screens in the windows - they were laying outside on the ground, and a strong odor of cat urine. We found the cat trying to get in the house. I have lots of photos to back up everything I have stated.. It was so shocking the state the house was in. We complained immediately after we picked our jaws up off the floor. The caretaker was confrontational, and the owner promised a refund if we didn't leave a bad review and then ghosted us. Photos are doctored, the house is poorly maintained, and it was a completely disappointing experience. This is our fifth trip to the Bahamas and we have never encountered anything even remotely like this place. VRBO should take the listing down until it is safe to rent and accurate photos are taken"
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
Explore more hotels
- Stella Maris Resort Club
- Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort
- The Sands Hotel
- Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove
- The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks
- The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks
- Coconut Bay Bahamas
- Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views
- White Ocean Coral - Private Beach Villa
- Beachfront family home steps from the perfect secluded ocean beach.
Frequently asked questions
How much do hotels in Rum Cay cost?
In Rum Cay, you can find cheap options in a few different ways. To see the availability, enter your chosen trip dates, then fine-tune your search by amenities, budget and more. Remember that prices can differ depending on when you plan to go, so if you have some flexibility, swap your dates around until you find the right deal.
When is the best time to go to Rum Cay?
That depends on what you want from your trip to Rum Cay. If you choose to visit in summer, which is between June and August, expect average temperatures of between 28ºC and 28ºC. Rum Cay has a tropical savanna climate, so keep that in mind when packing.
How can I find cheap hotels in Rum Cay?
Find inexpensive hotels with minimal effort by making use of our filter tool. Choose the "Price per night" box to view budget-friendly picks in Rum Cay. You can also look at our cheap hotels in Rum Cay page. The lowest available price starts from per night.
What are the best hotels in Rum Cay for families?
The first step to a great family escape in Rum Cay is finding the right place to stay. Go to the "Traveller experience" section of our filter tool and select "Family friendly." This will show you all the Rum Cay options that welcome children and have family conveniences such as babysitting and recreational activities. Choose the one that fits your budget and style, then get ready to relax while the little ones have fun.
Why should I book my Rum Cay hotel with Expedia?
Expedia is your one-stop shop for organising the ultimate Rum Cay holiday. You'll find a wide range of hotels to choose from and handy search filters that make it easy to find the stay of your dreams. Worried about your plans changing at the last minute? Many of our hotels offer flexible cancellation policies, so you can book with peace of mind. Get more out of your trip with Expedia Rewards. Join today for free to start collecting points and unlocking membership perks. You'll enjoy instant access to Member Prices, with savings worth 10% or more on select hotels.
