Baldwin Harbor Holidays from NZ$3,169

Loved the size of the rooms and location of the hotel.

Refreshed and good conditions in terms for building maintenance. Bedding has a little crum like stuff for two days. Escalator going up to the lobby was broken for whole 4 days.

Unique experience, operated through codes, but decent locality, clean hotel, close to mid town

Hotel was very very clean. The staff at front desk was okay. New guy was training. Had to keep asking for help. Took a while. Room was very clean. Smelled very good. Bed was okay. Valet is not 24 hours. And the “ parking “ for 10 dollars is probably a 10-15 min walk away. So good luck finding parking on the street. Decent spot. Not sure it was worth 350 a night but it was clean and no major issues.

I had a really pleasant stay here. The room was clean, spacious, comfortable, and well stocked with everything I needed. After long days walking around New York, it was a great place to come back to and actually relax. The location was perfect for my trip. It’s extremely close to the subway, which made getting around the city really easy, and it’s also within walking distance of food, shops, and anything else you might need. Being close to Gantry Plaza State Park was a huge bonus too — it made for a beautiful walk and a great view of Manhattan. Overall, this was a convenient, comfortable, and reliable place to stay. I’d definitely consider staying here again, especially for easy subway access and a quieter home base outside the busiest parts of Manhattan.